The reason is that it was an express train -good chance of succeeding. Of course it is sad that she took her life in this manner but people are not rational whne they do this. it has NOTHING to do with it. Steve@CPFC - 100% agree with all of your posts on this thread. She would have known this if she had been thinking about it previous to the act, but did it anyway. I very much doubt that she took her own life so that people would miss their flights from Narita. A bullied teen's last tweet revealed her despair from relentless teasing two days before she jumped in front of a train in New York City. It's very sad. It seems some people don't understand the meaning of the word 'selfish': lacking consideration for others. A mess, yes. We should be sad that a woman couldn't face anymore life and think of her family who have lost a loved one. DS Rees said: Leighane Redmond had several debts in several forms. A six-month-old baby boy died Friday after a woman jumped in front of an oncoming subway train at St. Clair West station. Auto Loans by Suruga Bank do not require permanent residency to apply. MoriNoHogosha; very brave of you to come here and post how you feel.Suicide is seen by many as a dirty and nasty thing. The coroner said Ms Redmond was mainly carrying Melsadie during the time she was at the station, but was also seen walking hand in hand with her at various stages. I personally think the whole 'ganbare' and 'I must not make a scene' are partially to blame. A woman in Mumbai's Kandivali area committed suicide by jumping in front of a Mumbai local train on Wednesday afternoon. Antonia Paget For Mailonline One last thing: I don't think it's entirely wrong to criticize this woman's act to an extent. It might not get better. Yubaru: "But seriously here, counselling is available for those that look for it. I always wonder if train jumpers are so frustrated w/ society, that this is their final, middle-finger salute. I think you completely missed the point of my 'taking it out on others' comment - I'm not referring to her killing herself, I am referring to her doing it in public, needlessly traumatizing so many others. Woman is left 'looking like Rose West' thanks to unflattering Tory Eurosceptics could take TWO WEEKS to decide whether to back Rishi Sunak's Brexit deal for Northern Watch as shoplifter puts BACK products he's trying to steal after live CCTV hub tells him: 'You're being Is YOUR lifestyle good for your heart? 3) While they are probably aware they will cause major inconvenience to the company and other passengers, and worse (as is the case here with the people hit by her body), they know they will be seen and found. Many here seem to think that suicide is a matter of choice as is the means to commit the act. A few reasons, I would imagine, although of course I'm also at a loss as to why people feel the need to off themselves. is rational - at least for now! The main thing is mental ilnnes should be seen and treated as any other illness. The week a train derailment poisoned an entire town in Ohio, the transportation secretary, the man in charge of preventing train derailments, held a press conference attacking White construction . Everyone could feel and understand each other as much as they understand themselves and events like this would probably cease to exist. Furious motorist is fined 650 after council worker paints disabled bay around his parked car. "I have been late 3 times this month because someone thought to throw themselves in front of a train.". I think it is wrong and low class to criticise someone who found that this was the best thing for them. Ignorant selfish act, saw this on the news last night looked horrible and the people that got hit by her flying body must be traumatised. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts. Terrible and selfish. Reports suggested that the woman was accused in a case. DS Rees agreed that Melsadie was 'behaving well' and did not 'appear to be demanding' until the mother and daughter were seen leaving the station. A police official familiar with the case said . But also unlucky. It's a shame that because of her actions others were hurt, and with the Japanese being as they are, I doubt as well that others were traumatized by this woman's actions as well. Too bad about the woman who died, but I'm glad for the four who apparently weren't badly hurt. Other people after all have nothing to do with their grief. A woman died after jumping in front of a Brooklyn-bound L train Friday night. According to police, the woman, Premalatha of Senthil Nagar in Urapakkam, had quarrelled . The 26-year-old woman has been identified as Sonakshi Garg. UPPER WEST SIDE, NY A woman died after jumping in front of a train at the West 72nd Street and Broadway subway station Thursday night, an NYPD spokeswoman told Patch. i pity those who commit suicide though it may be selfish to others but yeah, they are not in a sound mind to think about that. On January 8 2018, the husband took his two children to school and returned home to find the paperwork for the transfer of hospitals lying on the computer keyboard, before he discovered his wife had thrown herself in the path of a high speed train, tragically killing her and his unborn daughter. A smile or even some expressed concern, verbal or not, can go a long ways to helping ease someone's state of mind and break down barriers; at the very least, it will provide a brief reprieve for a troubled soul. Southbound 2 and 3 trains are running local from 96th Street to Times Square-42nd Street. Sorry to sound flippant, but every life lost is (often) another 3,4,5 scarred. I'm glad to see some compassion being expressed; who knows what unspoken burdens people carry around. while tragic, her act delayed thousands of people. In this case I'd bet she didnt want anything more than what she got. These adverts enable local businesses to get in front of their target audience the local community. 'On the day she had received news that some of her debt burdens had been relieved, if she had entered into a payment agreement which she did, and she was supposed to have started a new employment so her financial situation was potentially going to change.'. Also, Japan's teen suicide rate is among the highest in the world. The woman jumped in front of a southbound A train at Rockaway Boulevard around 10 a.m., policesaid. The . I don't care what people say about Trains its a very painfull way especially if you survive. alot of people do this to make other people suffer & have regret. When you are in a state of mind that jumping in front of a train is the best solution to your problems, you are in a very dark place indeed, and rational thought would be a struggle I'm guessing. If you must kill yourself, put your affairs in order first and choose a method that doesn't leave a gory mess. And the number is increasing - the year before was around 30.000. Registered in England & Wales | 01676637 |. inaccuracy or intrusion, then please Northbound 3 trains are running local from Times Square-42nd Street to 96th Street. It is true that mental illness is still taboo in Japan and that is a lot of the problem. If you are dissatisfied with the response provided you can If she'd had someone to listen to her - really listen - this might not have happened. Beaming Princess of Wales watches a young boy backflip during St David's Day Mike Tindall's latest money-making scheme! Why, of course it is! 'Selfish' is a description, not a judgement. Some like yourself may contemplate and be abel to stop the urges and possibly get help For soemthey may get further and feel there is no help or they are so far gone into the darkness to be helped. They don't realize how much of a mental block depression puts on a person. ( ) A. left B. arrived C. went D. returned. I don't know the severity of that woman'situation, so I can't say what pushed her over the edge, but I doubt she had any people she could be open with or even had a shoulder to lean on. The investigation into the woman's death is still ongoing, police told Patch. Kate Oh invites you to a Small Works Group Exhibition for the New York K-Art Festival! Thoughtless, yes. 'This is a gesture or activity which appears to have shown deliberation and forethought. Ms Redmond then brought Melsadie back over the gate to the public area of the platform, before returning up the stairs to the bridge over the platforms. Felicia Garcia, 15, was reportedly tormented by her peers at Tottenville High School, who teased her about sexual encounters with football players, police sources told the New York Daily News. Theres NO reason to be a coward & end it. If you have lived throug or witnessed a love one living through the hell of severe mental illness you would know why i say these things. herefornow - Taking time to put one's affairs in order first and considering how to end it all without harming others are both ways for the suicidal person to put their problems in perspective, see things in a different light and at the very least give themselves a chance to rethink what they're about to do. Japan Then again, she may not have been depressed at all. The incident occurred as the train was pulling into the Lorimer Street station around 7:42 p.m., according to. Brooklyn, NY - A 43-year-old woman was killed when she jumped in front of a northbound C train at Nostrand Avenue and Fulton Street in Flatbush at around 10:20 p.m. on March 19. How absurd and heartless to say, "legalize suicide". Describing the footage, Mr Wade said: 'She takes Melsadies hand and walks relatively slowly. With 35.000 suicides per year, it is not the lady who had a problem, but the society which is inducing people to suicide. As for counselling, this country's culture is built on saving face. If the person can redirect their thoughts to include others, they're more likely to realise that things aren't that bad and so less likely to actually commit suicide. I saw this on the news this morning, and it was truly horrible. Fax: +81 3 5829 5919 As a subscriber, you are shown 80% less display advertising when reading our articles. Smorkian; FOR GODS SAKE!!! I doubt she thought that she would harm anybody else in the process, and it's wrong to assume she wanted to. Police had few immediate details, but said the person may have jumped in front of the subway. With our first child, she had severe post natal depression. It was an awful experience. 2) The person could commit the act suddenly and without others knowing what is about to happen. The main problem for most people that commit suicides in Japan is a prolong isolation and stress. Zara's husband announces a two-month tour with his rugby podcast 'We met a Princess'! That's what this woman did, she took her personal problem and ruined a whole bunch of strangers' lives with them. Have it government regulated? So, after that experience I'm not so keen on excusing those people. She had jumped in front of the train with her . My friends husband died last year through suicide. The law is illogical and wrong, because it can make you to use "super glue" ,so to speak, to join each family member together 24/7 for just having peace of mind. 16:07 GMT 13 Nov 2020 As Cleo said - a permanent solution to a temporary problem. Her life ,her decision, her responsibilityshe is (or was) an adult with full responsibility and legal rights for goodness sake! "It's a shame that because of her actions others were hurt, and with the Japanese being as they are, I doubt as well that others were traumatized by this woman's actions as well.". So what's the point trying to analyze it? All of you who said "she was selfish" knew her right? DS Rees confirmed that such an arrangement had been agreed, before taking the hearing through the hours leading up to Ms Redmond's death. Your lack of compassion for someone who is obviously driven to the end of her wits psychologically for reasons none of us is privy to is staggering. I like Cleo's comment about those contemplating suicide, taking time to get their affairs in order and as a ancillary benefit, truly sitting down to evaluate and think. In this case I'd bet she didnt want anything more than what she got. We are no longer accepting comments on this article. The only selfish people are those who criticised this poor woman.Please show her and her family some respect. If she were aware enough of her surroundings and were able to fully assess her situation, she likely wouldn't have jumped in the first place. As for the deceased person, as we do not know anything about her, it is a little early to judge her motives. In a startling incident at the Dadar station Maharashtra's Mumbai, a woman jumped before a train. Many would feel they are losing face by going to a counsellor, that that's a sign of weakness. TOKYO. Cleo-summed it up best. The act of suicide is not usually selfish becaus ethe victims mindset is beyond that. Perhaps this is too 'clean' or 'romantic'. So yes, prevention starts in the early years. A Long Island Railroad train bound for Rockaway Beach was gliding into the East New York Station at Atlantic Avenue and Manhattan Crossing about 5 o'clock yesterday afternoon when the. See, I bet this woman wished she could have been part of that society too, going to work, having a routine, getting on with an ordinary life, having someone to complain to, to vent, to get it out of her system. JR will be amply compensated for this, as in all other suicides. I think we all have contemplated it at one time or another? Join the leaders of English Education for Children in Japan! Data returned from the Piano 'meterActive/meterExpired' callback event. Northbound 5 trains are running local from Third Avenue-149th Street to 180th Street. I was going to call the mental health service team but she said she did not want them to visit, she said they interfered with her marriage and her pregnancy,' he said. She took care.'. Compassion is free. And if you want to do something to help someone before they get in this desperate position, a little bit of kindness and understanding really helps. (Just read today's article about women running into problems with loan companies. Not one of you seem to consider that maybe this woman had fallen into depression due to the current situation caused by TEPCO or the Earthquake / Tsunami. The comments below have been moderated in advance. What a waste! We also have to consider the underlying cultural mindset. She was taken to Mount Sinai West, where she was pronounced dead. Another example of what happens when emotions are pent up through the pressure of life in Japan. Still, I was always somehow conscious of the fact that there are better options. Perhaps you propose a fine be imposed? Mr Wade said: 'Melsadie is pretty well behaved. Some subway lines were rerouted. Samaritans | Every life lost to suicide is a tragedy | Here to listen. Just legalize euthanasia. And then, once they are gone, the constant wondering of "Could I have done more?" ), I am even more horrified. A heavily pregnant woman died this morning after jumping in front of a high-speed train - also killing her unborn baby. She died at the scene. Police say although there were no eyewitnesses to the incident, the events were captured by a station security camera. To those who have lost a loved one to suicide, me included, compassion is needed. Awareness of the effects of one's actions on others yet choosing in one's own favor is a requisite of selfishness, and this woman, in all likelyhood, wasn't. British Transport Police had declared the deaths a suspicious incident and an investigation was launched by their Major Crime team. British Summer Time begins in March but do you wind your watch forward Britain braces for brutal -9C Arctic snap: Met Office warns more snow and ice could lash the country next Could Northern Ireland become the UK's Silicon Valley? - Just nuts man!!! It is being investigated by police as a suspected case of 'child destruction . I know they are not in their normal state of mind, but still, if one wants to end his/her life it's better to do it quietly and away from people's eyes. Several witnesses . Cut her some slack. Four shoppers sustained minor injuries in the incident. How on earth her family have to pay ? Of course if professionals could have reached this person first the outcome may have been different. Take the quiz: How well do you know LIV Golf? Sad story. A train fatally struck a woman after she jumped onto the tracks at Bay Parkway Station in Bensonhurst on Wednesday morning, police confirmed. If you are screwed up, go into that forest at the foot of Fuji and do us all a favour PS - don't wanna sound callous, she may have been mentally sick, but it's possible this selfish woman has destroyed other people's lives. By She may have lost everything. maybe we should look at why it is getting worse and what we can do. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. Seems the bottom line in some of these posts is "I don't care about you or what you do, just don't inconvenience us.". If you've been impacted by this story, Samaritans is a confidential emotional support service for anyone in the UK and Ireland. People who commit suicide are selfish and in this case she even hurt innocent bystanders. But before that can even happen, the stigma in society of seeking help needs to be broken. The MTA confirmed that somebody was hit at the station and that 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 train service was affected by the ensuing emergency response. Stressful start to National Offer Day? If you have a complaint about the editorial content which relates to Plus, in Japanese society, past and present, there is NO stigmata on suicide. Thank You. Princess Diana's nieces Lady Eliza and Amelia share 'Appalled and sickened but not surprised at all': Fury of Covid families as WhatsApps 'show Matt Hancock Head over heels for Kate! 40.680481 -73.843731. Gleams Akihabara 703 Wrong signal. Suicide is complex, but without a doubt, there needs to be FAR more done here for mental illness. Chiyoda-ku This individual may well have killed someone, or caused PTSD. This woman was obviously highly coordinated, had excellent timing and gymnastics ability. How is this not a fundamentally very selfish act? The ability to comment on our stories is a privilege, not a right, however, and that privilege may be withdrawn if it is abused or misused. Mr Wade said: 'The next thing she appears to do, she does when no member of the public is in her immediate vicinity. At this low point rational thinking is almost gone, the main thing is to end the life. I had a good friend kill themselves when I was young and a family member threaten to me to do so (while in the hospital, dying). 'Usually when she had an episode, the signs were lack of sleep, lack of appetite and being angry but she was normal before and after the incident,' husband Jude said at the inquest into her death on Thursday. I understand it completely. to seek help? I doubt if she needs any now. Key Highlights. The lives that are always involved, the innocent people that have to suffer because the person wants to go out in style. No one as far as I can see is accusing suicides in general or this woman in particular of being malevolent. Those ads you do see are predominantly from local businesses promoting local services. A Gannett Company. The following service changes were implemented, according to the MTA: If you or somebody you know are having suicidal thoughts call the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline at 800-273-TALK (8255) or call 1-888-NYC-WELL (9355) to speak with a counselor. The unidentified victim was pronounced dead at the scene. However, they returned just 12 minutes later at 8.17pm. I am absolutely amazed how many people on this message board knew the deceased person. NDTV delivers reliable information across all platforms: TV, Internet and Mobile.Subscribe for more videos: https://www.youtube.com/user/ndtv?sub_confirmation=1Like us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/ndtvFollow us on Twitter: https://twitter.com/ndtvDownload the NDTV Apps: http://www.ndtv.com/page/appsWatch more videos: https://khabar.ndtv.com/videos?yt The victim was pronounced deceased at the scene. For confidential support call the Samaritans in the UK on 08457 90 90 90, visit a local Samaritans branch or click here for details. New Delhi: A woman jumped in front of the Delhi Metro train at Model Town Metro station on Saturday and committed suicide. I even came close once, and I probably would not be sitting here typing this if not for intervention. Cleo - would you agree that the definition of selfish could also be applied to the people here who are lacking in consideration for someone who was pushed to the ultimate extreme of taking her own life? I dont believe that the people who saw what happened really have registered in their minds what they saw. That's truly sad. By doing so, you will also receive an email inviting you to receive our news alerts. tired of the traffic backed up from suicides? I am not trying to be rude but making statements like "taking it out on others" is ridiculous. The posts that are concerned about the effect on others (the people who were injured, the people who had to witness what happened, the families that have to cope with the aftermath, etc - No, I don't think expressing concern for those people is selfish. The identity of the woman is unknown at this time. . Everyone here is making very very good points - but then everyone here (I am presuming!)